Budget 2026: Image rights tax reform brings confusion, not clarity

At the 2025 Budget, the Government announced its intention to “clarify the tax treatment of image rights to ensure that all image rights payments related to an employment are treated as taxable employment income”.  Given the legislative radio silence that followed, there was quiet optimism that the Government had shelved these plans.

At the 2026 Budget, the Chancellor doubled down, with draft legislation (here) and draft HMRC guidance (here) published in the days since, the latter setting out when HMRC would consider image rights payments to be employment earnings and so subject to income tax and NICs.  The new rules will come into effect from 6 April 2028.

Alex Goodchild of the Bray & Krais Sports team explains how the proposed legislation goes much further than anticipated and, rather than “clarifying” perceived “inconsistencies”, could produce arbitrary results, with payments that are plainly not employment-related in danger of falling in scope where there is even the most incidental involvement of the football club.

Premier League clubs making image rights payments also face a potentially significant double penalty as employer NICs are factored into Squad Cost Ratio (SCR) calculations.

“Related to an employment”

The key question is whether an image rights payment is “related to an employment” of the individual.  That will be true where the image rights payment falls into any one of three cases:

  1. it is made by the employer or a person connected with the employer;
  2. it is made by a third party, but “arranged or otherwise facilitated” by the employer/a connected person; or
  3. it is otherwise made “by reason of the employment”.

Employer payments

The first category is straightforward and using a deeming test comparable to the one used in the employment-related securities regime brings welcome clarity.

Effectively, if a club pays a star player a sum for enhanced use of the player’s image and personal appearances (e.g. in the club’s own promotional materials and its sponsorship campaigns with commercial partners), that sum will always be treated as employment earnings.  This applies regardless of whether the arrangement is documented in the employment contract or a separate image rights agreement and whether the payment is made to the individual or to an image rights company.

If the Government’s intention was to put an end to the longstanding debate as to whether such payments should be treated as additional remuneration, then so far, so clear.

“Arranged or otherwise facilitated”

These terms will not be defined in statute and HMRC advise that whether the employer has arranged or facilitated should be clear on the facts.

This limb is broad and, judging by the examples in the draft guidance, partly serves an anti-avoidance purpose.  Clubs seeking to leverage players’ images in their sponsorship programmes which would otherwise be caught by the deeming test might have been able to take payments outside of the employment regime by arranging for commercial partners to contract with and pay players separately, with the club collecting a sponsorship fee net of those player payments – although query how contractually viable such arrangements would have been in practice.

The draft guidance suggests HMRC are alive to and would pursue arrangements of the type just described.  HMRC would also consider the employer to have arranged or facilitated the payment where the sponsor approaches the club, the club negotiates the terms on the basis selected individuals will participate, and the sponsor pays player and club separately.

Players’ separate personal deals

However, the words “otherwise facilitated” are broad and alarmingly could extend beyond the anti-avoidance motive and into the player’s own personal sponsorship deals.  On the one hand, it is welcome that HMRC clarify that an employer:

  • consenting to an individual entering into a separate arrangement (e.g. personal endorsement) with an unconnected sponsor (a common club protection in club-player contracts); or
  • passing on the employee’s contact details to the sponsor,

will not on its own count as arranging or facilitating – but it should be self-evident that those arrangements are not employment-related.

It is less obvious why HMRC consider the employer to arrange or facilitate image rights payments in the following fact patterns:

  • club recommends a player to a sponsor;
  • player is not represented by an agent, sponsor approaches club in respect of that specific player, club arranges a meeting and negotiates on behalf of the player, club receives no payment in respect of the player’s deal; or
  • player is not represented by an agent, sponsor approaches club in respect of that specific player, club makes the introduction in return for a fee, but has no involvement in negotiations between the player and the sponsor.

In practice, any star player a brand wishes to engage will almost invariably have an agent, so these examples are hopefully hypothetical.  Regardless, HMRC’s interpretation of “arranged” and “facilitated” risks arbitrary results: a small introduction fee or the club negotiating on behalf of a player could infect the whole personal deal so that payments are taxed as earnings, when another otherwise identical deal without those facts would be taxed differently.

As covered in our previous blog, clubs are increasingly enthusiastic about acquiring control over use of the player’s image rights in the personal context, sourcing deals on behalf of the player and benefitting financially via a revenue share mechanism.  That arrangement would also be caught by “facilitated”, despite being one where most ordinary people would struggle to trace an employment relationship.

“By reason of the employment”

This is a familiar concept in the employment tax code.  Case law establishes that something will be “by reason of the employment” where employment is an operative cause.  In other words, employment need not be the sole cause or even the dominant cause.  However, a payment will not be “by reason of the employment” where employment is only an incidental factor.  Each case turns on its facts.

In fairness, HMRC reassuringly accept that an individual being sought out for endorsement deals thanks to their celebrity as an elite sportsperson and a personal brand built on their performances and recent success will not, by itself, render the image rights payment “by reason of the employment”; employment is simply an incidental factor.  This also suggests HMRC do not plan to run extreme arguments that it is the player’s status as a player for a leading club that “facilitates” the branding opportunities.

This reassurance is then undercut by a series of seemingly random and inconsistent criteria in the draft guidance which HMRC say point to employment being the operative cause in deals which the player has arranged, such as:

  • whether the player has enjoyed recent success with other clubs or whether they have just won the league for the first time with the current club;
  • whether the campaign materials allude to the club’s recent success: copy such as “for winners” points to operative cause, when generic descriptions of the player as “elite” or “winning” do not;
  • the inclusion in campaign materials of visual themes corresponding to the club’s colours; and
  • the sponsor being based in the same area as the club.

It feels odd, in particular, that employment-related status could turn largely on the sponsor’s creative choices.  In reality, most robustly negotiated image rights agreements will prohibit a player’s personal endorsements from referring or alluding to the club or its branding, and the player in turn will want approval rights in the sponsorship deal, but these factors, like geography, do not originate with the club or the player, and arise in the creative process, not when the deal is sourced or negotiated.  Fundamentally, the test asks why the player is paid – a personal sponsor trading on a club’s success may drive the engagement of its fans, but this seems a tenuous basis for treating personal deal payments as earnings.

HMRC guidance of course merely reflects HMRC’s opinion of the law, and tribunals would hopefully take a more common-sense approach, but the examples given only serve to increase uncertainty and cut across the stated policy behind the change, which is to resolve inconsistencies.

Wider implications

The ramifications of this recharacterisation are far-reaching beyond income tax treatment, payroll admin and the attraction of employee and employer NICs.

  • From the image rights company’s point of view, a consequential amendment to the Corporation Tax Act 2009 will mean that expenses of the image rights company, such as admin and legal expenses, are not deductible to the extent attributable to image rights payments that are caught as earnings. Equally, image rights payments taxed as earnings are left out of account in calculating the company’s trading profits to avoid double taxation.
  • In an IR35 case, Manchester United club ambassador Bryan Robson was able to successfully argue that to the extent payments to his personal services company by Manchester United were consideration for the exploitation of his image rights, those payments fell outside the scope of IR35. As the draft legislation gives the Treasury power to make regulations, before 6 April 2028, on how the intermediaries rules interact with the new image rights regime, that partial defence may well not survive.

The unwelcome and more significant surprise for Premier League clubs is that employer NICs count as a squad cost for the purposes of the Squad Cost Ratio rules, under Rule A.1.22(a)(iii).  Assuming clubs are broadly making image rights payments around the old tier one club cap of no more than 15% of their commercial revenues, the 15% employer NICs contribution could be a cost in the millions, which is not insignificant when compliance with the thresholds can come down to fine margins.

Concluding thoughts

The deeming test for image rights payments made directly or indirectly by employers is useful, but for players’ own third party deals, the breadth of the other two triggers and HMRC’s draft guidance introduce unwelcome confusion.  The line between club-sourced and facilitated deals that are in substance designed to benefit the club and independent player deals with the most innocent involvement, or the faintest suggestion, of the club is alarmingly unclear.

More than ever, players, clubs and their advisers will need to assess the risk of independent arrangements carefully and meticulously document the deal’s source and substance, as well as the club’s involvement in negotiations.

RELATED

THE TIMES’ “BEST LAW FIRMS 2027”

We are delighted to share that Bray & Krais have been named in The Times’ “Best Law Firms 2027”. The article highlights our involvement in the Oasis “Don’t Look Back in Angerâ€...

Read more >

THE TIMES’ “BEST LAW FIRMS 2026”

We are delighted to share that Bray & Krais have been named in The Times’ “Best Law Firms 2026”, being commended for both entertainment and sports. The article highlights both our ...

Read more >

Court rejects appeal against “Thinking Out Loud” decision

The US Supreme Court has rejected the appeal, made by Structured Asset Sales (SAS), against the decision to dismiss the second copyright case over Ed Sheeran’s “Thinking Out Loud...

Read more >
< BACK TO INSIGHTS